Tom Levy stood up first: cautious with small number of radiocarbon dates, need more, we have 35 high precision dates from Edom dating to the 10th century.
Bill Dever: pottery the same as post philistia pre israelite level at Gezer, def early: is Finkelstein here or is he dead?
Gitin: If the site only lasts for 20 years how can you connect it with Shaaraim? Garfinkel: Perhaps data passed by writing?
Jeff Chadwick: Any thought to dating to early-Solomonic period and destruction to Shishaq. Garfinkel: dates to first half of 10th century based on olive pits in destruction level. But perhaps.